Butt Plugs

Butt Plugs

Set it and forget it.

A butt plug does one job well: it stays put and gives you full, steady pressure while you get on with everything else. If you're shopping for a beginner butt plug, go small, with a tapered tip and a flared base, then work up from there. Already comfortable? Try heavier glass or steel, a vibrating butt plug, or something with texture.

Guaranteed Discretion Shipped in plain packaging, backed by a 30-day satisfaction guarantee.
Free Shipping Spend $99 or more, and shipping's on us anywhere in the US and Canada.
Built for Health and Pleasure Since 2017, we’ve paired premium devices with straight-talking education.
Guaranteed Discretion Shipped in plain packaging, backed by a 30-day satisfaction guarantee.
Free Shipping Spend $99 or more, and shipping's on us anywhere in the US and Canada.
Built for Health and Pleasure Since 2017, we’ve paired premium devices with straight-talking education.
Clear all
Glass anal training set: three clear glass plugs in graduated sizes
Three clear glass anal training plugs lying on bed sheets

Glass Anal Training Set – 3 Pieces

$55.00 USD
(4.5)
Add Glass Anal Training Set – 3 Pieces to the cart
Polished stainless steel anal plug with a teardrop bulb and T-shaped base
Stainless steel anal plug lying on white sheets

Stainless Steel Anal Plug

$50.00 USD
(5.0)
Add Stainless Steel Anal Plug to the cart
Notify Me When Back in Stock
Triple Strike kit: three black silicone anal plugs in small, medium and large
Hand holding the three Triple Strike silicone anal plugs to show their size

Triple Strike Silicone Anal Plug Kit – 3 Piece Set

$45.00 USD
(4.5)
Notify Me When Back in Stock
vulcan prostate massager with cock ring
wearable prostate massager

Vulcan Vibrating Prostate Plug

$120.00 USD
(5.0)
Add Vulcan Vibrating Prostate Plug to the cart
Crawler tentacle butt plug in red fading to purple with a wide flared base
Crawler tentacle butt plug lying on black sheets

Crawler Tentacle Butt Plug - Silicone

$30.00 USD
(4.7)
Add Crawler Tentacle Butt Plug - Silicone to the cart
Octo-Twist magenta and teal tentacle anal plug with suckers and a flared base
Octo-Twist tentacle anal plug standing upright

Octo-Twist Silicone Anal Plug

$37.00 USD
(5.0)
Add Octo-Twist Silicone Anal Plug to the cart
Small clear glass butt plug with a tapered tip and flared base
Small glass butt plug lying on linen

Glass Butt Plug - 3.5in

$25.00 USD
(4.5)
Add Glass Butt Plug - 3.5in to the cart
Clear beaded glass butt plug with four graduated beads and a flat base
Hand holding the beaded glass butt plug to show its size

Beaded Glass Butt Plug 7.25in

$60.00 USD
(4.5)
Add Beaded Glass Butt Plug 7.25in to the cart
PlugTopus magenta tentacle butt plug with a blue flared base
PlugTopus tentacle butt plug lying on black sheets

PlugTopus Silicone Butt Plug

$39.00 USD
Add PlugTopus Silicone Butt Plug to the cart

Not Sure Which One Fits?

Tell us what you've tried and how much you want to feel. The quiz gives you one recommendation, not a page full of options.

Find my match

Browse More Collections

Cock Rings
A tighter grip for longer sessions.

Cock Rings

Stainless Steel Sex Toys
Weight you can feel.

Stainless Steel

Glass Dildos & Butt Plugs
Solid, sleek, and built to last.

Glass

Fantasy Dildos & Toys
Built for a bigger imagination.

Fantasy

p spot massagers
Designed around anatomy, not guesswork.

Prostate Massagers

Butt Plugs FAQs

What size butt plug should I start with as a beginner?

Go small, with a tapered tip. A training set with a few sizes is an easy route: start with the smallest and move up when you're ready.

What's the difference between a butt plug and a prostate massager?

A plug stays put and gives a feeling of fullness. A prostate massager is curved to reach the P-spot. Some plugs do a bit of both, with an angled tip or vibration built in.

Why do butt plugs have a flared base?

So the plug stays exactly where you put it. Only use toys with a flared base or a handle for anal play.

Silicone, glass, or stainless steel?

Silicone is soft and flexible, so it's the comfortable pick for longer wear. Glass and steel are firm and smooth, with a weight you can feel, and you can warm or cool them first.

What lube should I use with a butt plug?

Water-based lube works with every plug here, and lots of it. Skip silicone lube on silicone plugs, since it can damage the surface.

Is the packaging discreet?

Yes. Orders ship in plain packaging, and billing is discreet.